Vegan Passions Forum

STEP 1) Click Into Any Category - STEP 2) Click NEW TOPIC - STEP 3) Post! It's that simple!
Members with accounts over 24 hours old are encouraged to click into the Introduction Area category to say hello!
Have fun!


Post new topic   Reply to topic    Vegan Passions Forum index -> Animal Rights
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
former member default image - bird flying away

Posted:     Post subject: PETA

No other animal rights group has become as much of a lightning rod for criticism as People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and portions of that criticism are somewhat valid. Having said that, I still support them for two very big reasons.

First, whatever their methods I truly believe their intentions as an organization are legitimate and pure and their overall goals are extremely noble and worth fighting for. In spite of all the somewhat mixed messages they send and the "LOOK AT ME!" stunts to grab attention, at their core they just want what we all as ethical vegans want. A world free of injustice, falsehoods, irresponsibility, and cruelty where humans allow animals the space, freedom, and dignity they were endowed with by nature before humans ever existed on this planet.

Secondly, FWIW I think the original founders, Ingrid Newkirk and Alex Pacheco, are wonderful people and their intentions when they created the organization were only to help animals and free them from the cowardice and cruelty of mankind. As an agnostic I'm not convinced there is any form of heaven or hell, heck I'm not convinced of anything. However, if it turns out there is a heaven and an afterlife and there exists a just god or gods then these two have already secured their spot there because I cannot think of too many other people who are better examples of the potential nobility and courage of humanity than Ms. Newkirk and Mr. Pacheco. They will always be heroes to me no matter what.

However, and it does pain me to say this because I wish it wasn't so, there are a lot of aspects about the way PETA operates which I strongly disagree with. For starters, their penchant for euthanizing animals sends a very bad message and costs them and the animal rights movement a lot of support and credibility. I know PETA has offered what they believe to be unavoidable reasons for euthanasia but with all due respect if other organizations such as the ASPCA can make a stronger effort to encourage adoption from shelters and spaying/neutering as opposed to killing then I can't see why PETA cannot do the same.

Another thing which bothers me is PETA's decision to pick fights with other animal rights organizations or individuals such as the ASPCA, Friends of Animals, or the late Steve Irwin. Nothing saddens me more than people within the animal rights movement fighting amongst themselves. We should be fighting against our common enemies and trying to unite the entire, and admitedly broad, spectrum of the animal rights movement under one tent rather than splintering and weakening it with petty infighting. If PETA has legitimate criticism of other animal rights groups it should open constructive dialog without trying to destroy them completely which ends up doing more harm than good. Having PETA left standing as the only AR organization isn't going to make things better. The more people and groups fighting for the rights of all animals the better things will be and the quicker things will change.

Lastly, and this is what bothers me the most, is PETA's strategy of enlisting any and every celebrity it can in order to give the false impression that Hollywood is somehow a bastion of decency and compassion towards animals. I do not doubt there are some individuals out there such as Bob Barker, who in spite of being only vegetarian instead of vegan has done more to promote animal rights than any other Hollywood celebrity I can think of, that are truly devoted to helping animals and do so with honor and integrity. Others such as Joaquin Phoenix, Alicia Silverstone, and Pamela Anderson seem to be earnest in their love for animals although in the case of Ms. Anderson her rather promiscuous image is such a sideshow that it detracts somewhat from the message in spite of its merits. Oh well, still I'd rather have her with us than against us since her heart seems to be in the right place. The problem is that for every celebrity who is acting with conviction and principle there are a number of selfish, hypocrite, "posers" for whom appearing in a PETA ad is nothing more than public self-promotion and who know nothing about the animal rights movement and couldn't care less about animals if it gets in the way of their career or their personal satisfaction. There is a certain individual who I won't mention by name but he has played the character of Spiderman in film who was quoted as basically saying he doesn't give a dang about animals but he became vegan in order to improve his health. When PETA enlists such an individual, and they did, it sends the message that all there is to veganism is a vegan diet and that helping animals is only a worthwhile endeavor provided you get some primary benefit out of it. Enlisting another celebrity such as Silverstone or Phoenix who are vegan for both moral and health reasons sends a much more useful and positive message. It seems there is no one that PETA won't work with. Even one of the Kardashians has appeared with PETA and I'm sorry but the moment you start trotting out any member of that family as a tool for trying to convince people to act honorably and with compassion your message is going to run off the tracks. Then you have the case of someone such as Bill Maher who is apparently on the PETA board of directors but who seemingly wants nothing to do with any part of helping out animals if it intrudes on his greed and self-appetites. In a Larry King interview he was quoted as saying that in spite of PETA's endorsement of veganism he still consumes meat and animal products and that he "does not march lock-step with everything PETA says". So here we have not just any individual but one who sits on the PETA board openly putting down what I consider the most important message PETA proclaims which is a call for veganism. If that doesn't send a destructive message I don't know what does. He goes on to offer as justification for his decision to contribute to the suffering of animals the fact that "animals eat other animals" and he sees no reason why humans shouldn't do the same. He even had the gall to say that the difference is that animals don't kill with cruelty. Well Bill, problem is that when you consume animal products you are contributing to the pain and suffering of innocent creatures because, unlike animals, humans do kill with extreme cruelty. He also conveniently ignores the fact that humans differ from animals in their ability to *nalyze the choices they make and in knowing the consequences of such choices.

Like I said, overall I still support PETA because this world needs more people fighting for justice not less but I wish People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals would rely less on people who might be famous and rich and more on others who may lack fame or wealth but are full of compassion and conviction. Ok, time to end my speech because I am going to go eat. I think I will have some vegan bean burritos with a nice helping of fresh green salad. If you have anything to add to what I wrote I'd love to read it when I come back.

Back to top

former member default image - bird flying away

Posted:     Post subject:

`The flaws you list of PETA make me question the validity of supporting it. Given that there are better organizations, it seems better to direct our energy/funds towards them instead.

Back to top

former member default image - bird flying away

Posted:     Post subject:

veganpantheist wrote: `The flaws you list of PETA make me question the validity of supporting it. Given that there are better organizations, it seems better to direct our energy/funds towards them instead.

Well, honestly I like the way the Humane Society and the World Society for the Protection of Animals(WSPA) go about pushing for animal rights. They basically have the same message as PETA but without all the fake celebrities or the naked ladies.

Having said that though, I can't bring myself to throw PETA completely under the bus because back in my early days when I was just barely beginning to become conscious and aware of man's inhumanity and the suffering it inflicts on all other creatures it was the famous PETA videos that helped me to see things clearly and steered me towards a path that would finally lead towards adopting a complete vegan lifestyle and philosophy....albeit it took some steps to get there. I was far more influenced by the undercover videos of circuses, fur farms, dairy farms, slaughterhouses, puppy mills, etc... than by videos or posters with celebrities. Somehow, those are much more poignant than having some celebrity giving you a generic and, in some cases, empty message. They can have a poster or video of Forrest Whitaker saying he's vegan, Heidi Klum pledging to go naked rather than wear fur, or, and yes they actually did this, have Ron Jeremy telling you to spay/neuter your pet but somehow it just doesn't speak to your conscience like seeing a poor animal skinned alive or cramped up in a cage looking at you with an expression of suffering in its eyes. The animals are asking for your help in those videos and unless you aren't really human you can't help but be jolted into deep self-introspection and even extreme anger or guilt.

I think that is when PETA really works best and it is what I'd like to see more of and less of the celebrities and the stunts. Oh, the other reason I can't stop supporting PETA is that they supposedly work, albeit clandestinely, with the ALF and other similar groups. It is how they were able to obtain much of their undercover footage I would suspect. So if the ALF, which definitely doesn't pull any punches when it comes to animal rights, thinks PETA is worth keeping around a bit longer then so do I. Anyway, even if PETA is not everyone's cup of tea they can always choose one or more of the other fine organizations that promote animal rights at the local, national, or international level. More importantly, as individuals we can make a difference by being aware of the fact that our choices in life make a positive or negative impact in the lives of animals. As the saying goes: "No act of kindness, however small, is ever wasted."

Back to top

Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Vegan Passions Forum index -> Animal Rights All times are GMT - 6 Hours
Page 1 of 1


© phpBB Limited

Friendfinder Homepage Image

Home | Search

| Contact | Advertise on this Site

| Journalists, Bloggers & Press Inquiries

| Online Dating Directory Webmasters

| Terms | Privacy Policy

© 2004 - 2024